We Make Zines

a place for zinesters - writers and readers

I've gone on about this a little here and there in WMZ, so maybe there's not much point in rehashing it, but maybe it's worthwhile to approach it from another angle. I imagine I may step on some toes and get myself into trouble.

When reviewing zines, I sometimes got a few that didn't have any postal addresses for people to contact. At least one even seemed to discourage postal contact. The idea behind doing their zine was just to promote their web activity. That left me cold...and I'm getting colder still, the more I see of the new "zinedom".

How many of you refuse or refrain from publishing a physical address FOR OR IN your zine, either on the Internet or Papernet?

How many of you refuse to send your zine to Zine World because you don't want to have a physical address published?

If you don't mind having it published in Zine World or the papernet, then why are you concerned about publishing it on the Internet?

Does it concern you that when you make your zine available only to people with Internet access, you may be discluding people who cannot or choose not to access the Net?

I can see including Net addresses, but not Net addresses ONLY.

It seems that "zinedom" in it's present evolution (or devolution, depending on your perspective), is gradually becoming less and less friendly to the papernet AND PAPERNETTERS.

I remember the old Factsheet 5 and how awesome it was. This whole "web-centered" zinedom is such a far, sad cry from that. The old FS5 had the feel of an old basement flea market. The new webocentric "zine scene" has the feel of a suburban mall.

I'm seriously considering seceding from it. But would I just be cutting my hand off?

Something to ponder.

Views: 390

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

The only reason I haven't put a physical address on my zine is because I don't have a PO Box, and I'm way too paranoid to be handing out my home address, even if it is to a relatively small number of people. I do give my email and online shop addresses though, which is the best I can do until I get a PO Box.
I think, as most people have said, the only reason I won't be putting an address on my zine is because I don't have a PO box. That said, I've included my email address and would happily send out my address to anyone who contacted as long as they sounded OK people!
The only reason I have 3 zines complete and not yet printed is because I've been waiting for weeks to find out what my new PO box address will be! It does feel really important to me to have a physical address in there, it just wouldn't seem like a true paper zine without it!
Hello everybody. I've just announced my new issue of .Zap!!omania, #4, on the New Issue Announcement Thread. I discuss this matter, and Zines & the Net, mutually vis-a-vis, in general.

I particularly reply to reply to bibliophile83 & Clementine. You can look at the post if you're interested.

Alan, Zacery & Heath, your copies are in the mail.
I put my physical address on one zine I made, but when I reprinted it I got rid of it because I didn't live there anymore.
Last time I lived somewhere (Vancouver, up to July of this year) I had 5 addresses in 17 months. Since then I haven't really had an address at all (travelling). It wasn't even worth me putting a physical address on the zines. As I didn't know if I'd be somewhere in a week/month, let alone a year in the future.

Whereas, my email address is going to stay the same for a long time.
I include both physical address (PO Box) and website/e-mail address in everything. The PO Box because I enjoy doing trades and getting something random in my box will pretty much guarantee that I'll send something back (and I love doing that). The website/e-mail because I enjoy people contacting me and that's another way for them to do so. Besides, my e-mail address is pretty much permanent (or at least as permanent as those things can be) and is a backup in case I ever wander away from this area. Plus, for issues of one of my zines (Haiku a Day) I put the previous month's issue up online as soon as I mail out the current month's issues, and that's a way to find them.
PO Box is how I operate. Emails are much less fun to get. I'd rather get an order in a letter, maybe with a sticker of button. And I put my PO box on my zines and stickers

PO BOx 6025
Richmond, VA 23222

write me ; )
I only put my email because I'm worried about safety. I can't afford a PO box (why are they so expensive where I am?! everyone here always says how cheap they are!) and I live with my parents, so I try to keep my address out of things. then again, I do tons of trades... but I feel if I can scope out someone's profile and see that they've spoken to other people I've traded with... it feels like a bit of a safety net.

but I don't discourage mail contact AT ALL. as long as I've spoken with a person, I am more than happy to swap addresses and do things the old fashioned way.

I wish I could have experienced the old scene...

Your point is well taken. As zinesters, we have a real commitment to the published word. It seems counter intuitive for a zine to provide a digital over a physical address.  However -- on the most practical level -- I look back on the many address and PO boxes I have had over the years. I can think of at a dozen as I type this. Also, I have found old zines with dead addresses printed in them. It just seems that an email address is better way to go.

Oh and NO, I don't think its a good idea to publish your actual home address (ever). I did it back in the day, but that was a simpler time. (grin) yeah, I'm old.

I will put a physical address on the zine once I get a P.O. Box. With the internet being what it is, anyone can find your home address in about 90 seconds (if it even takes that long!), but I'd still rather not put it out there.

I just flipped through a phone book, the kind that have been distributed free to every doorstep for ages.  The residential section has hundreds of thousands of names, all with their home address in them.

I bought a bunch of old comics last summer.  One was a Dennis the Menace, ca 1960.  It had a pen pal club for kids and it listed their age and home address to write to.  They were in about the 9 to 12 range, give or take.

This last Sunday I was on a run on the Centennial Trail in Spokane.  A man with a rock tied to a string was attacking people.  Apparently he was psychotic.  There are dangers everywhere.  What's the use in hiding in our holes?

Soon, I'm going to put out some ads and use my home address.  I'm a mail junkie and I want to get some mail on my front porch, in addition to the POB and PMB I have.

Don't get me wrong.  I'm not nagging, begging or chiding people to print their home address, but I honestly question how dangerous it is.  Erwin S. Strauss, for one, publishes his home address and a number of other zinesters do as well.  I've never heard of the ever-feared scenario of the psycho zine reader from hell showing up on a zinester's doorstep.  Yes, it could happen.  Maybe it has.  But put in context, is it any more dangerous than anything else we do in daily life?

Unless it sounds very, very intriguing and like it has a lot of potential, I refuse to "PM" a zinester for their address.

It's not a matter of blindly hating the Net, it's just a matter of wanting to chip away at how it spreads and takes everything over.  A couple days ago I called a pizza place to phone in an order.  They wouldn't take it.  No.  I had to order it on-line, by filling out a form.  This is a complete first for me.  The simple and convenient act of ordering at a restaurant by phone, talking to a real person, became unavailable.  It was too "yesterday". I want to try to resist this ridiculous level of techno-trendy narrowness.

Here's a discussion I had on another forum that's somewhat germane to this question: 


"I've never heard of the ever-feared scenario of the psycho zine reader from hell showing up on a zinester's doorstep.  Yes, it could happen.  Maybe it has."

There was an instance of a zinester being assaulted by a prisoner she had been in contact with, who was later released and assaulted her. It has happened. I think it's really dismissive to say, "Hey, why not send predators directly to your door? No big deal, cuz you could die in a car accident anyway." I feel like maybe you have never been a woman? ::she gently puts it::

EDIT: The more I think about this, the fact you are putting "the papernet" above personal safety, the more I am just like, "are you effing kidding me?!" James, I respect you, but this is just one way too far. The typical woman does not want her home address published in a general venue. Please just believe me on this. This is a true statement well prior to any threat of the internet. There used to not be many choices for this kind of safety issue (PO Box or bust!). Now there are other options. Please respect people's choices to use them, for whatever reason. Hey, if you aren't willing to PM someone for their physical address, I respect that, too.



Want to advertise here?

Ist preference given to distros and zines. Rates and details are here. Limited space. Very Low Cost!

Please Support Our Sponsors




Download and Print WMZ Fliers


© 2017   Created by Krissy Ponyboy Press.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service